Devices & Accounts

A Hospital's Information Was Entered from Outside — Unauthorized Access to Tokushima University Hospital, and How to Protect the Information of Patients and Staff

Security Lab — kurashiki-bouzu

Hello, I am Kurashiki Bouzu (kurashiki-bouzu), born in 1971. I am a former funeral director, and I now live in an old house in Kurashiki, Okayama, working together with my AI butler, Moka.

This time, the story is about a hospital’s information. A university hospital’s systems were entered from outside, and concerns arose that the information of patients and staff — 18,920 people in total — might have been exposed. A hospital’s information is information deeply tied to people’s lives: the very fact of having received a test is part of it. The place where that information gathers was targeted through an outside door.

The result first

Here is the conclusion, up front.

What happened — what the announcement confirmed

What can be confirmed from Tokushima University Hospital’s notice, “On the Possibility of a Personal Information Leak,” is the following.

The wording of the announcement matters here, too. “Concern of exposure,” “possibility.” It is not written that a leak has been confirmed. There are traces of entry. But no clear trace has been found of information having been taken outside or misused. This article keeps that same line.

The entrance — what was reported as the hospital’s explanation

The hospital’s notice document itself does not record the details of the route — from where the entry was made. However, as the hospital’s explanation, the Asahi Shimbun and the Yomiuri Shimbun conveyed the outline of the route. As the range of reporting, it is set apart here.

What deserves attention here is the nature of the arrangement said to have become the entrance. An arrangement used for training at home is, by design, made on the premise that one “enters from outside.” A door that can be entered from outside the home is convenient — but if its lock is weak, it is a door for anyone outside, too. The story of repeated login attempts is also the story of that door’s lock being tried, again and again.

To repeat: these route details are not written in the hospital’s notice document; they are the range that reporting conveyed as the hospital’s explanation. The cause published in the document goes only as far as “unauthorized access from outside.”

The information that was involved, and the information that was not

The targets divide into two arrangements.

The specimen testing arrangement (blood, urine, and so on)

The nursing career support system

Together, 18,920 people. What was not included should also be written clearly. There are no test values. There is no credit card or financial information, either.

On the other hand, there are two points that cannot be taken lightly. One is that passwords were included on the nursing career support system side. The hospital, in its FAQ, asks people to reset their passwords as needed. If the same password was also being reused in other arrangements, it becomes material for trying the keys of those other arrangements as well. The other is about the patients’ information. The test items and values were not included, but the very fact that “during that period, at that hospital, I had blood or urine tested” is information from deep within a person’s life. In a later correction to its FAQ, the hospital indicated that the fact of having visited a medical institution, and the patient information handled there, may amount to “personal information requiring special care.”

The hospital’s response, and the roughly two months until the announcement

The hospital’s response and its course from here are as follows.

The hospital also explains, in its FAQ, why the announcement took roughly two months. In order to identify the scope of the impact accurately, it worked with an external specialist organization to examine access records and communication histories closely, and it took time to identify the affected patients and staff without error. And, so that those affected could be informed individually at the same time as the announcement, it prepared the post and email arrangements. The explanation is that it “prioritized accuracy and safety,” and it says it will work toward providing information more promptly in the future.

There are two entrances — entered from outside / carried out from inside

The entrances through which a hospital’s information is put at risk are not only the “entered from outside” form of this case. There is another: the “carried out from inside” form. Information is copied onto a small, portable tool — such as a USB memory stick holding records — and taken outside, or the tool itself is lost. Even with the same hospital information, the door is in the opposite place.

The tools for guarding these two are different. The guard against the entered-from-outside form is to layer the door’s locks (multi-factor authentication), to close arrangements that do not need to be entered from outside to the inside of the hospital only, and to watch for traces of attempted entry. The guard against the carried-out-from-inside form is to decide and manage the tools and occasions on which things may be carried out, to keep records of copying, and to narrow the information carried itself. With only one of the two, the other door stays open. Reading this case as a story of the “outside door” side is, I think, the accurate reading.

How to protect — in a form that applies to ordinary workplaces too

Finally, the lessons for the protecting side. The prevention measures the hospital named are, as they are, a model of how ordinary workplaces can protect themselves.

For those who hold information (hospitals, companies, shops)

For those who entrust information (patients and users)

The lines — what is not known

The bigger the uproar, the more the lines matter. As of this article, here is an honest list of what is not known.

A hospital’s information is not only about illness and tests. It is the very footprints of a life: “when, at which hospital, and for what business I was involved.” The more conveniently the doors that can be entered from outside are used, the more the responsibility for those doors’ locks and watch shifts. This incident, I think, showed that obvious thing again, from the side of a large hospital.

Sources


Entrance (other languages)

日本語 中文 Español 한국어 Français Deutsch हिन्दी العربية

Devices & Accounts / Back to the English top